User Profile

Gertie MacDowell Locked account

undauntedgirl@books.boxpleats.com

Joined 1 year ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

2025 Reading Goal

16% complete! Gertie MacDowell has read 3 of 18 books.

Emily Brontë: Wuthering Heights (Paperback, 2020, [publisher not identified]) 4 stars

Wuthering Heights is an 1847 novel by Emily Brontë, initially published under the pseudonym Ellis …

A classic I respect but don't necessary like

4 stars

Content warning Plot spoilers herein

Charlotte Brontë: Jane Eyre (French language, 1984) 4 stars

A worthy classic

4 stars

This was my first ever Brontë novel (no, really). I was of course familiar with the literary family but had never read any of their work (for no purposeful reason). So it was with a degree of excitement that I started Jane Eyre wondering what the popular Victorian novel could hold.

I enjoyed it from the start, and I enjoyed it more as I devoured it over three days of a holiday. Certain anachronisms aside, the social commentary was informative, and the character of Jane Eyre remarkably fresh given her age. Her personal growth throughout the novel (along with other characters') was probably the best I'd read up until that point.

Some aspects of the story I found a bit weak but overall it was a satisfying ending in the context of the time and place.

Elizabeth: The enchanted April (1993, Pocket Books) 3 stars

"A notice in The Times addressed to 'Those Who Appreciate Wistaria and Sunshine' advertises a …

Only sort of enchanted.

3 stars

This book started off a bit slow but got going once the four main characters were in Italy. Of course by then the ending was clear as day but I was still wondering how it would all happen, which it does. That said, the plot came a cropper by the end with each character's development becoming progressively more unbelievable and I was left bewildered on the last page and pondering whether, in real life, such personal changes would be permanent.

Overall, not a bad book but not one for the favourite pile.